Thomas Minguy, "An Underground Current in the Theory of Desire"
Work in Progress Seminar Series | Winter 2023
“An Underground Current in the Theory of Desireâ€
Thomas Minguy
Friday, January 20, 2023
3:30-5:30 PM
Leacock Building, Room 927
Abstract:
In this paper, I frame Benedict Spinoza’s notion of desire in terms of a pleasure-principle. The philosopher famously defined human essence as desire, and so to analyse how this essence is organized, how it navigates the world according to what one could call, with Laurent Bove, a set of existential strategies, establishes a firm ground on which we can approach the remainder of Spinoza’s thought. But the concept of desire has quite a track record in philosophy, and so to distinguish the Spinozian version from others is far from being simple.
The interpretation I offer here has two main implications.
On the one hand, I answer the following: how is desire organized in Spinoza’s philosophy? My argument relies on the pivotal role of pleasure in the move from desire as a form of inertia and desire as an expansive movement. Most of the argument here relies on a close reading of a few propositions in the Ethics, accompanied by a discussion of the readings of Yirmiyahu Yovel and Eugene Garver that also discusses this shift in Spinoza’s description of what Michèle Bertrand called “affective economyâ€.
On the other hand, I confront Spinoza’s conceptualization of desire with a contemporary contender, namely, the Freudian understanding of psychic life as cashed-out in terms of desire, also ruled by a pleasure-principle. Freud, I suggest, remains within a teleological understanding of desire. This gives to Spinoza’s theory a subversive dimension.
Together, these two moments show that a reading of Spinoza’s philosophy grounded in the conception of desire I propose helps us to reframe Spinozian thought as a peculiar form of libertine philosophy.